A prominent Muslim cleric facing deportation is
testifying in Newark in his fight to make the United States
his permanent home.
KEVIN R. WEXLER / SPECIAL TO THE RECORD
Mohammad Qatanani addresses supporters at the
federal complex in Newark before testifying in his
deportation trial.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security wants to deport
Mohammad Qatanani, the imam of the Islamic Center of Passaic
County in Paterson, because the agency says he lied when he
failed to disclose in a 1999 application for permanent
residency -- or "green card" -- that Israel convicted him in
1993 for "assisting Hamas."
Qatanani, who came to the United States on a religious
visa in 1996, this morning told the court about his
childhood and growing up poor in a Palestinian refugee camp.
He says he wanted to be a mosque leader since he was six
years old, following in the footsteps of his father.
He has argued before that he didn't note the incident
involving the residency application because, although he was
detained for three months, the Israelis did not charge or
him or convict him.
Though immigration officials claim that documents
provided by the Israelis include a confession in which
Qatanani admitted being a member of Hamas from 1989 to 1991,
U.S. authorities have failed to produce it despite demands
from the imam’s lawyers.
In addition, FBI and Immigration and Customs Enforcement
officials testified last month that in a 2005 meeting, the
imam informed them of the arrest and a past link to Hamas,
which the United States lists as a terrorist group.
The 44-year-old imam says that he was tortured while in
detention and that, under duress, he signed a document that
was in Hebrew.
Aref Assaf, a spokesman for the imam, said that Qatanani
did not, as the FBI and ICE officials testified, refer to
his detention by Israelis as an arrest. Assaf also said that
the imam did not tell the officials in the 2005 meeting that
he had once had links to Hamas. That meeting was at
Qatanani’s request to discuss the government’s delay in
processing his application.
Assaf, a Denville resident and member of the Paterson
mosque, said that former Passaic County prosecutor Ronald
Fava was at the 2005 meeting with the imam as his attorney
and on Monday will take the stand to refute the U.S.
officials’ account of what Qatanani said.
"This is a respected attorney and former prosecutor,"
Assaf said. "This is the only way we can rectify the record
about what was really said. What the U.S. government claims
the imam said is a total lie."
In hearings last month, expert witnesses testifying for
Qatanani described the Israeli court system in the 1990s as
one that routinely trampled over the rights of Palestinians
and arbitrarily arrested and detained them.
The experts, who included scholars, lawyers and an
official with Human Rights Watch, said that Israelis would
not have held Qatanani for only three months if they had
believed he had ties to Hamas.
The deportation trial is being closely watched by Muslims
and non-Muslims alike across the state.
Qatanani is widely respected among many of the state’s
political and religious leaders of various faiths as a
devoted proponent of peace and for bringing different groups
together.
His mosque has hosted interfaith gatherings that have
featured Gov. Jon Corzine and Rep. Bill Pascrell, among
other political leaders. He was the first Muslim leader to
officiate at the opening of the New Jersey General Assembly.
Many often praise him as one of the first imams in the
nation to denounce the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and
terrorism. After the attacks, he provided space in the
mosque to FBI officials, who set up tables to recruit Arabic
speakers.
In Immigration Court, prosecutors for the government have
tried to chip away at Qatanani’s reputation as moderate and
replace it with the portrait of a man with a dark,
lesser-known past.
Many Muslim leaders view the deportation effort against
Qatanani as evidence that even the champions of moderation
in their community cannot shake the labels of extremism and
terrorism.
"This is religious lynching," Assaf said.
Still, many Qatanani supporters say they’re feeling
cautiously optimistic.
They believe that on the stand, Qatanani will project the
qualities that have made him beloved among so many across
the state.
"I’m hopeful and almost confident that once the judge
hears him he’ll allow him to stay here," said Hesham
Mahmoud, who lives in Rutherford. "I think the judge will
see the decent human being who does nothing but spread the
message of love and unity. The imam is a very humble
person."
Technically, the decision before Immigration Court Judge
Alberto Riefkohl is whether to approve Qatanani’s new
application for U.S. residency for himself and, by
extension, his wife and three of his six children. The other
three children were born in the United States.
The judge is expected to issue a written decision. That
could take weeks, or even months, said the imam’s attorney,
Claudia Slovinsky of Manhattan.
"This case is more than about just one person," Assaf
said. "This case has far-reaching political implications. It
puts Israel on the stand, and what not just one person
endured under them, but what hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians have endured under the Israelis."
E-mail:
llorente@northjersey.com