He's resigned himself to leaving the United
States if that's what immigration officials
insist on after reasonable investigation.
IMAM Mohammad Qatanani cannot drive. That's a
major problem for a man with six kids who need
to be chauffeured to school and other
activities.
But with no license, he has little choice:
Either he arranges for other members of the
Muslim community to help him run errands, or he
goes about his business on foot. What a fine
mess for one of North Jersey's most influential
spiritual leaders.
A Palestinian educated in Jordan, Qatanani
heads Paterson's Islamic Center of Passaic
County. He agonizes over what might have
happened if someone hadn't come along to take
his son to the hospital after the boy's stomach
ache proved to be appendicitis.
He's been without a license for the past
three years, unable to show the Motor Vehicle
Commission enough points of identification to
get his license renewed while his immigration
status is in question.
When he arrived here in 1996 on a religious
work visa, Qatanani was able to get a license.
But now that his application for citizenship is
being challenged by immigration officials, he's
had no luck trying to get back behind the wheel.
Losing his driving privileges is a minor
inconvenience alongside the possibility that he
might lose his fight for citizenship.
Immigration officials said he failed to disclose
a conviction on his original application.
Immigration officials say he was untruthful
on his first application because he didn't
mention that he'd been detained by the Israelis.
Qatanani, 44, had a run-in with Israeli
police who held him because of an allegation
that he had helped the Palestinian extremist
group Hamas, which he steadfastly denies.
Qatanani and his lawyer say that he was detained
briefly in 1993 and released from what he
thought was an insignificant detention. There
was no trial, Qatanani said. But American
immigration officials found an Israeli document
indicating that he'd been convicted of aiding an
extremist group.
The imam did not account for the incident on
his citizenship application, so immigration
authorities are treating it as more serious than
a simple detention. They say he deliberately
omitted the information.
Although a hearing is set for May on his
reapplication, and many elected officials attest
to his positive role as a conciliator, hope is
not a word he's encouraging his congregation to
hang on to. He's resigned himself to leaving the
United States if that's what immigration
officials insist on after reasonable
investigation.
A somber mood descended on the Islamic
center, which was packed for its regular Friday
noon prayer service. Some congregants were
stunned as Qatanani laid out his situation for
those who didn't already know.
"It was very fatalistic," said Aref Assaf,
president of the American Arab Forum. "He said,
'Do not let the institutions die or wither away
because the person in charge may not be here
with you tomorrow or the next day. So whether
I'm here or not, you shall prosper.' And people
were almost crying because he was saying to
them, 'goodbye'."
The immigration dispute also threatens to
derail his children's education. Paying for
college has suddenly become a big question mark
because of the challenges that threaten their
father's chance for citizenship. His three
youngest are American-born, and the three eldest
are approaching college age.
Widely praised as a builder of bridges
between Arabs and non-Arabs, his record as a
conciliator is being overshadowed. Qatanani's
stature has grown here as a religious leader
accommodating to non-Muslims and public
officials. He's even allowed anti-terrorism
officials and recruiters to address Muslims at
the Islamic Center.
His application is dragging on because of the
nationwide backlog of immigration applications.
At the end of last year, 45,200 citizenship
requests were waiting to be processed in New
Jersey, nearly 2 1/2 times the number in the
pipeline during the previous years.
"His application that was submitted in 1999
took almost seven years for him to get the
denial," said Assaf. "The delay is more
pronounced for our community, because racial
profiling shows its ugly face. They treat us
like we're guilty until they prove us innocent."
If someone as involved with conciliation as
Qatanani is dealt such a heavy-handed blow,
others will be unlikely to cooperate in times of
crisis.
Lawrence Aaron is a Record columnist. Contact
him at aaron@northjersey.com. Send comments
about this column to
letterstotheeditor@northjersey.com.